Past Nominees
1st Annual American Reality Television Awards (2013)
Hall of Fame/Humanitarian
Gillian Larson/Reality Rally
Production Company
Mark Burnett Productions
Overall Show
The Voice
New Show
Duck Dynasty
Reality Royalty Award – Queen
Khloe Kardashian
Reality Royalty Award – King
Si Robertson
Host/Hostess
Ryan Seacrest – American Idol
Villain
Abi-Maria Gomes – Survivor
Performance
Jessica Sanchez
Dynamic Cast-Recurring
Storage Wars
Docu-Series
Duck Dynasty
Unique Concept
Betty White’s Off Their Rockers
Competition Show
The Voice
Judging Panel
The Voice
Badass Crew (Outstanding Production Crew)
Deadliest Catch
Guilty Pleasure
Jersey Shore
Shocking Moment
American Idol
Heartfelt Moment
The Voice
Game/Variety Show
Family Feud
Spin-Off
Top Chef
Talk Show
Ellen
Sore Loser Moment
Jeff Kent, Survivor
Theme Song
Dancing w/ The Stars
2nd Annual American Reality Television Awards (2014)
Hall of Fame/Humanitarian
Donald Trump/Celebrity Apprentice
Production Company
One Three Media
Overall Show
Deadliest Catch
New Show
MasterChef Junior
Reality Royalty Award – Queen
Lisa Vanderpump
Reality Royalty Award – King
Blake Shelton – The Voice
Host/Hostess
Betty White
Villain
Abby Lee Miller/Kevin O’Leary – Dance Moms
Performance
Top 20, SYTYCD
Dynamic Cast-New
Hell’s Kitchen
Dynamic Cast-Recurring
Duck Dynasty
Docu-Series
Pitbulls & Parolees
Feel Good Show
Pitbulls & Parolees
Unique Concept
Betty White’s Off Their Rockers
Competition Show
The Voice
Creative Challenge
RuPaul’s Drag Race
Judging Panel
The Voice
Badass Crew (Outstanding Production Crew)
Deadliest Catch
Guilty Pleasure
Snooki & JWOWW
Editing
Deadliest Catch
Shocking Moment
Preachers’ Daughters
Heartfelt Moment
MasterChef
Reality Duo
Sig & Edgar
Dramatic Exit
Dancing w/ The Stars
3rd Annual American Reality Television Awards (2015)
Hall of Fame/Humanitarian
Heidi Montag & Spencer Pratt – Hall of Fame
Production Company
Original Productions
Overall Show
Hell’s Kitchen
New Show
Wahlburgers
Reality Royalty Awards – Queen
Leah Remini
Reality Royalty Awards – King
Blake Shelton – The Voice
Host/Hostess
Gordon Ramsay
Villain
Abby Lee Miller – Dance Moms
Performance
America’s Got Talent – Emily West
Dynamic Cast-New
MasterChef Jr.
Dynamic Cast-Recurring
Dance Moms
Docu-Series
Vanderpump Rules
Feel Good Show
Pitbulls & Parolees
Unique Concept
Married at First Sight
Competition Show
The Amazing Race
Creative Challenge
Big Brother
Judging Panel
Dancing w/ The Stars
Badass Crew (Outstanding Production Crew)
Deadliest Catch
Guilty Pleasure
Hell’s Kitchen
Editing
The First 48
Shocking Moment
Deadliest Catch
Heartfelt Moment
American Ninja Warrior (Kacy Catanzaro)
4th Annual American Reality Television Awards (2016)
Hall of Fame/Humanitarian
Janice Dickinson – Hall of Fame
Production Company
ITV Entertainment
Overall Show
ITV Entertainment
New Show
Born This Way
Reality Royalty Award – Queen
Vicki Gunvalson – Real Housewives of Orange County
Reality Royalty Award – King
Todd Chrisley
Host/Hostess
Todd Chrisley
Villain
Abby Lee Miller – Dance Moms
Performance
Sawyer Fredericks – The Voice
Crossover Talent
Julia Louis-Dreyfus
Dynamic Cast-New
Born This Way
Dynamic Cast-Recurring
RHOC
Docu-Series
Little Women: LA
Lifestyle Show
Ellen’s Design Challenge
Feel Good Show
Pitbulls & Parolees
Unique Concept
Dating Naked
Competition Show
American Ninja Warrior
Creative Challenge
RuPaul’s Drag Race
Judging Panel
The Voice
Badass Crew (Outstanding Production Crew)
Deadliest Catch
Guilty Pleasure
Big Brother
Editing
The First 48
Digital Reality Series
Making A Murderer
Shocking Moment
Botched
Heartfelt Moment
Dance Moms (Jojo Siwa)
Reality TV Website
TMZ.com
5th Annual American Reality Television Awards (2018)
Production Company
44 Blue Productions
Overall Show
America’s Got Talent
New Show
Martha & Snoop’s Potluck Dinner Party
Reality Royalty Award
Snoop Dogg
Host/Hostess
Leah Remini
Villain
Chad Johnson/Scott Disick
Performance
Adam Klein – Survivor
Dynamic Cast – New
Amazing Race (Season 28)
Dynamic Cast – Recurring
Deadliest Catch
Docu-Series
Vanderpump Rules
Lifestyle Show
Fixer Upper
Feel Good Show
Pitbulls & Parolees
Lifestyle Show
Fixer Upper
Feel Good Show
Pitbulls & Parolees
Unique Concept
Cast Me!
Competition Show
America’s Got Talent
Creative Challenge
Big Brother (Season 18)
Judging Panel
RuPaul’s Drag Race
Badass Crew (Outstanding Production Crew)
Deadliest Catch
Guilty Pleasure
Hell’s Kitchen
Editing
Naked & Afraid
Digital Reality Series
ANW: Crashing The Course
Shocking Moment
RuPaul’s Drag Race (Lady Gaga)
Heartfelt Moment
Undercover Boss
Heartfelt Moment
Dance Moms (Jojo Siwa)
Digital Reality Star (2017)
John Cena, Our Home
TMZ.com
Reality TV Website
PerezHilton.com
Game/Variety Show
The Price is Right
6th Annual American Reality Television Awards (2019)
Production Company
Fly On The Wall Productions
Overall Show
Pitbulls & Parolees
New Show
Top Chef Junior
Reality Royalty Award
Tamar Braxton
Host/Hostess
Steve Harvey – Celebrity Family Feud
Villain
Kevin O’Leary – Shark Tank
Dynamic Cast-New
Queer Eye
Dynamic Cast – Recurring
Vanderpump Rules
Docu-Series
Jersey Shore: Family Vacation
Lifestyle Show
Property Brothers
Feel Good Show
American Ninja Warrior
Unique Concept
The Zoo
Competition Show
America’s Got Talent
Judging Panel
World of Dance
Badass Crew (Outstanding Production Crew)
The Amazing Race
Guilty Pleasure
My Cat From Hell
Editing
Team Ninja Warrior
Digital Reality Series
Top Chef: Last Chance Kitchen
Reality TV Website
RadarOnline.com
Game/Variety Show
Ellen’s Game of Games
FAN FAVORITE – Big Brother
Tyler Crispen
FAN FAVORITE – Bachelor Nation
Colton Underwood
FAN FAVORITE – Real Housewives
Kandi Burruss
FAN FAVORITE – Ninja Warrior
Drew Dreschel
FAN FAVORITE – RuPaul’s Drag Race
Trinity The Tuck
Digital Reality Star (2017)
John Cena, Our Home
TMZ.com
FAN FAVORITE – Bravolebrity
Stassi Schroeder
7th Annual American Reality Television Awards (2020)
Production Company
495 Productions
Overall Show
Hell’s Kitchen
New Show
Making It
Reality Royalty Awards – Queen
Jennifer Lopez
Reality Royalty Awards – King
Derek Hough
Host/Hostess
Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson
Performance
Kodi Lee-America’s Got Talent
Dynamic Cast-New
The Titan Games
Dynamic Cast-Recurring
Floribama Shore
Lifestyle Show
Property Brothers
Docu-Series
I Am Jazz
Lifestyle Show
Drag Me Down The Aisle
Feel Good Show
Hollywood Game Night
Unique Concept
The Aquarium
Competition Show
America’s Got Talent
Creative Challenge
The Titan Games
Judging Panel
The Voice
Badass Crew (Outstanding Production Crew)
Deadliest Catch
Guilty Pleasure
Dr. Pimple Popper
Editing
World of Dance
Digital Reality Series
I Want My Stuff Back
Game/Variety Show
Are You Smarter Than A 5th Grader
Kids Reality Series
American Ninja Warrior, Jr.
8th Annual American Reality Television Awards (2021)
Production Company
Sony Pictures Entertainment
Overall Show
90 Day Fiancé
New Show
Amy Schumer Learns to Cook
Reality Royalty Award
Dr. Sandra Lee, Dr. Pimple Popper
Host/Hostess
Wayne Brady, Let’s Make A Deal
Dynamic Cast-New
My Feet Are Killing Me
Dynamic Cast-Recurring
Crikey! It’s the Irwins
Docu-Series
Married To Medicine
Lifestyle Show
Diners, Drive Ins and Dives
Feel Good Show
America’s Funniest Home Videos
Unique Concept
90 Day Fiancé: Self-Quarantine
Competition Show
The Masked Singer
Creative Challenge
Restaurant: Impossible
Judging Panel
American Idol
Reality TV Moment
Pit Bulls and Parolees
Badass Crew (Outstanding Production Crew)
Jimmy Kimmel Live!
Guilty Pleasure
Crisley Knows Best
Editing
Shark Tank
Digital Reality Series
Gown & Out in Beverly Hills
Game/Variety Show
Jeopardy! The Greatest of All Time
Kids Reality Series
Kids Baking Championship
International Reality Series
Crikey! It’s the Irwins